Paradigm

Allison Gordon
Miami Country Day School

Experience Level: I have coached high school debate club since 2021. My direct experience in debate is limited to coaching and judging; I was not part of a debate club in high school or college.

Judging Philosophy: I value logical arguments supported by evidence and clear reasoning. My background emphasizes understanding diverse viewpoints, favoring arguments presented clearly and without excessive jargon.

Preferences:

Rate of Delivery: A pace that ensures understanding of the arguments. I can follow at a decent speed, but I would recommend prioritizing the quality of arguments over quantity.

Note-taking: I flow arguments and evidence and look for clash between the teams.

Criteria for Assessment: I consider the strength of the arguments, the evidence presented, the relevance to the topic, and the ability to engage with the opposing side's points. Dropped arguments are highly considered. Effective weighing and a strong impact, and, when applicable, framework can win you the round.

In-Round Conduct: Expect respectful discourse, with a focus on the quality of debate over theatrics.