Paradigm

Madalyn Frazior
Miami Country Day School

Experience Level: I have coached high school debate club since 2022. I also competed in speech events and Model UN in high school. In college, I did congress events and also competed in Model UN.

Judging Philosophy: I value logical arguments supported by evidence and clear reasoning. Clarity is the most important aspect for me when judging, as well as considering any counter points and having strong rebuttals. I also value including diversity of opinion.

Preferences:

Rate of Delivery: A pace that ensures understanding of the arguments. I can follow at a decent speed, but I would recommend prioritizing the quality of arguments over quantity.

Note-taking: I do flow arguments, and follow both evidence presented as well as countered by the teams.

Criteria for Assessment: I consider the strength of the arguments, the evidence presented, the relevance to the topic, and the ability to engage with the opposing side's points. Dropped arguments are highly considered.

In-Round Conduct: Expect respectful discourse, with a focus on the quality of debate over theatrics.